Skip to main content

Route 1 Introduction

This Route provides guidance and templates for procurements that are:

  • low value (a total estimated value of under £50k excluding VAT)
  • low risk
  • non-repetitive.

This Procurement Journey Route should only be used by individuals who are authorised to procure for their Scottish public sector organisation.

You do not need extensive procurement training, however it is assumed that you have an awareness of:

  • UK and Scottish regulations
  • applicable local procurement policies, guidelines and governance arrangements. 

If you are unable to estimate the value of a contract that contract will be explicitly made subject to the procurement rules.  More information can be found at What Procurement Route Should I Choose? and Thresholds.

If your procurement does not meet the above requirements, or you do not have the authority to procure, contact your Procurement Function or Centre of Expertise (COE) .

 

Route 1 Objectives

The main objectives of this Route are to:

  • provide a step-by-step guide to conduct a low value and low risk procurement exercise
  • provide a set of guides and templates that can be used to collate and analyse the data required for a Route 1 procurement exercise
  • standardise the Scottish public sector procurement process across organisations for low value procurements
  • highlight the minimum legal and policy obligations involved at each stage of the process.

Considerations Before Proceeding

Before you start your Procurement Journey, please consider the following points:

  1. Are the good/services you are buying business critical?
  2. Is there a significant risk to your Organisation's reputation or ability to deliver if something went wrong with what you are buying?
  3. Is the estimated value of the goods/services that you are buying more than £50,000 (excluding VAT) over the lifetime of the contract?  If so, this means that Route 1 cannot be used, as the contract needs to be advertised and formally tendered.

To calculate the estimated value of the contract you should add the spend for the full contract duration, including any contract extensions. 

For example, a contract of £10,000 per year (excluding VAT) over three years plus a 1 year £10,000 extension (excluding VAT) is a £40,000 contract i.e. 3 x £10,000 + £10,000.

If you are unable to estimate the value of a contract, that contract must be clearly made subject to the procurement rules.

Please note, requirements must not be 'split' into contracts of lower value, or contracts reduced in duration, to avoid the need to advertise/conduct a full tender exercise.

Points for consideration

  1. Are existing contracts already available that you could use e.g. call off from?
  2. Does your Organisation have a lower advertising threshold?  If so, should you follow the Route 2 processThis information will be held with your Finance Department or Procurement Function
  3. Is there a conflict of interest? Do you or someone in your Organisation stand to benefit from the outcome of the procurement?  For example: benefit financially? Have friendships with suppliers? Previously worked for suppliers? If so should the buyer and/or evaluating team be changed? 

If you have answered 'yes' to any of the above questions please contact your local Procurement Function or Centre of Expertise (CoE) before proceeding.

Audit Requirements

You should keep a file for your Route 1 procurement documents, in case of future audit.

You should make sure you are familiar with:

  • your Organisation's document retention policy
  • any guidance which may impact on the project before starting.

Please note that purchases of goods and services may routinely be the subject of Freedom of Information (FoI) requests.

Quote Distribution, Procurement Documents and Contract Award

Quote Distribution

Your quote should be sent to the suppliers you want to participate in your quote.  This can be done using the Quick Quote functionality in Public Contracts Scotland (PCS) or by other means e.g. in writing via email or by post.

PCS is recommended as:

  • you can search through a register of suppliers to select those you want to bid;
  • questions and answers can be provided through this system;
  • this will provide an audit trail for your quote.

Procurement Documents 

Your quote should include all of the documents a potential bidder would need to decide whether to bid or not e.g. your specification, and all the documentation required to be able to respond to your request for a bid e.g. a pricing spreadsheet that the bidder needs to complete. 

Prepare Documents provides a checklist of documents that should be included in your quote as a minimum. 

If using Quick Quote in PCS for your quote please note that the following file size restrictions apply for uploading documents:

  • 10Mb per document with a maximum of 40Mb for the Buyer
  • 10Mb per document with a maximum of 30Mb for the Supplier.

Contract Award 

Once you have completed all stages of your procurement you must seek approval on who to award your contract to. This approval process must follow your Organisation’s governance requirements.

Once approval has been received you should notify the successful and unsuccessful suppliers of the outcome in writing.  More information, including letter templates, can be found in the Contract Award station. 

Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Do you have what you need?

Before carrying on, please check you have everything you need:

  • Budgetary sign off and sponsorship;
  • Individuals with relevant experience to evaluate responses and write the brief;
  • Timescale plan.

You are now ready to begin Route 1 of the Procurement Journey.

Please ensure this guidance is used in conjunction with the internal governance, policies and procedures for your Organisation.

Route 1

This Route provides guidance and templates for procurements that are:

  • low value (a total estimated value of under £50k excluding VAT)
  • low risk and
  • non-repetitive.

This Procurement Journey Route should only be used by individuals who are authorised to procure for their Scottish public sector organisation.

You do not need extensive purchasing training, however it is assumed that you have an awareness of:

  • EU regulations
  • applicable local procurement policies, guidelines and governance arrangements. 

If your procurement does not meet the above requirements, or you do not have the authority to procure, contact your Procurement Function or Centre of Expertise (CoE) .

Route 1 Objectives

The main objectives of this Route are to:

  • provide a step-by-step guide to conduct a low value and low risk procurement exercise;
  • provide a set of guides and templates that can be used to collate and analyse the data required for a Route 1 procurement exercise;
  • standardise the Scottish public sector procurement process across organisations for low value procurements;
  • highlight the minimum legal and policy obligations involved at each stage of the process.

Before carrying on, please check you have everything you need:

  • Budgetary sign off and sponsorship.
  • Individuals with relevant experience to evaluate responses and write the brief.
  • Timescale plan.

Considerations Before Proceeding

Before you start your Procurement Journey, please consider the following points:

  1. Is the product/service you are buying business critical?
  2. Is there a significant risk to your Organisation's reputation or ability to deliver if something went wrong with what you are buying?
  3. Is the estimated value of the goods/services that you are buying more than £50,000 over the lifetime of the contract?  If so, this means that Route 1 cannot be used as the contract needs to be advertised and formally tendered.

To calculate the estimated value of the contract you should add the spend for the full contract duration, including any contract extensions. 

For example, a contract of £10,000 per year (excluding VAT) over three years plus a 1 year £10,000 extension (excluding VAT) is a £40,000 contract i.e. 3 x £10,000 + £10,000.

Please note, requirements must not be 'split' into contracts of lower value, or contracts reduced in duration, to avoid the need to advertise/conduct a full tender exercise.

  1. Are existing contracts already available that you could use e.g. call off from?
  2. Does your Organisation have a lower advertising threshold?  If so, should you follow the Route 2 processThis information will be held with your Finance Department or Procurement Function
  3. Is there a conflict of interest?  Do you or someone in your organisation stand to benefit from the outcome of the procurement?  For example: benefit financially? Have friendships with suppliers? Previously worked for suppliers? If so should the buyer and/or evaluating team be changed? 

If you have answered 'yes' to any of the above questions please contact your local Procurement Function or Centre of Expertise (CoE) before proceeding.

Audit Requirements

You should keep a file for your Route 1 procurement documents, in case of future audit.

You should make sure you are familiar with:

  • your Organisation's document retention policy; and
  • any guidance which may impact on the project before starting.

Please note that purchases of goods and services may routinely be the subject of Freedom of Information (FoI) requests.

You are now ready to begin Route 1 of the Procurement Journey.

Please ensure this guidance is used in conjunction with the internal governance, policies and procedures for your Organisation.

Lessons Learned

You should review all activities undertaken for the contract.  This will help you understand which areas performed well and areas for development.  The areas identified should be acted upon to make improvements for the future.

Lessons learned can be undertaken at any time during the procurement process, for example:

After a contract has been awarded

To understand the areas that need to be amended for the future

During the lifetime of the contract

In order to incorporate any best practice/problem solving identified or implemented as soon as possible to reap any benefits

After the contract has ended

To aid future decisions and new contracts

All staff and suppliers involved with the bid can be asked for feedback. These people may be in your organisation or external to your organisation e.g. bidders.

Feedback can be provided in a number of ways e.g. face to face meetings, online feedback, etc. and given by a variety of roles e.g. bidder contract managers, procurement officers, logistics, estate managers, etc.  However you should ensure that these people understand the process and are trained/experienced in providing this kind of feedback.

Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Lessons Learned - Example Questions

Questions which could be asked are:

  • what worked well?
  • what didn’t work well?
  • what would you do differently in the future?
  • were there any unresolved problems?
  • were any innovations, workarounds or solutions used?  If so, what improvements resulted?
  • do you have ideas for improvements for future contracts?
  • what contract areas were most important to you/your department?
  • what issues occurred which were not anticipated?
  • what extra costs occurred?
  • were there processes used that could be improved upon?
  • were there processes that are not needed?
  • can ICT (Information and Communications Technology) systems be used to improve performance?

Changes identified may not be in procurement areas e.g. you may suggest improving communications and/or processes between internal departments.

It must be recognised that any lessons learned data could be subject to a freedom of information request. As a result any information held should be objective.

 

You have now completed Route 1.

Please remember that procurement is a continual process: continue to use lessons learned in all procurement exercises.

Contract and Supplier Management

Purpose and Scope

Route 1 Contract and Supplier Management (CSM) provides guidance and tools/templates for contracts that are low value or low risk (or both).

For CSM guidance on medium to high value and risk contracts, please refer to Route 2 and Route 3.


Why CSM Matters

CSM s much more than administration. It is the bridge between awarding a contract and delivering the value from it. 

Good CSM:

  • enhances value for money
  • reduces risk of supplier non-performance, poor service or cost creep
  • supports innovation, continuous improvement and strong supplier relationships
  • ensures compliance with legal/regulatory obligations

The supplier’s performance should be managed throughout the lifetime of the contract to make sure they deliver the quality, service, cost and delivery identified in the contract award.

By managing the contract well, you can:

  • avoid contract surprises or escalating costs
  • make processes more efficient
  • manage changes more easily
  • ensure full and prompt payment to and through the supply chain

Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Roles and Responsibilities

Role

Responsibility

Examples

Contract Owner

Accountable for overall contract delivery
  • oversight of KPIs
  • budget holder
  • escalation

Contract Manager

Day-to-day management of supplier relationship
  • monitoring performance
  • recording variations

Contract User

Orders and/or receives goods or services
  • Ordering IT consumables only from the contracted supplier
  • Reporting delayed deliveries or poor service to the contract manager

Procurement / Commercial Team

Provides professional procurement advice
  • approvals
  • legal compliance
  • change control

Finance

Payment controls and budget monitoring
  • invoice approval,
  • compliance with terms

Supplier

Deliver goods/services in line with contract
  • meet KPIs
  • provide reports
  • provide management information/data

 

Contract Manager

The Contract Manager is, ideally, one person (or small team) and should be responsible for the contract. This helps with continuity, relationship building and knowledge retention.

The Contract Manager may not be the same person who awarded the contract, this can be beneficial because it allows fresh oversight.

Their responsibilities should be clear:. Roles, accountability, resources and time commitment should be defined.

The level of engagement should be proportionate to risk and value. For example:

Contract is low value, low risk to your organisation and there are many other substitute suppliers available e.g.  cleaning services for a small office area

The contract manager may not need to stay in regular contact with the supplier. 

The contract may effectively “run itself” with no issues and therefore the Contract Manager may decide to have a monthly (or quarterly) supplier call to go over any updates.

Contract is low value but high risk to the organisation e.g. IT software

The contract manager will be more involved to avoid issues and problem solve. 

For example, they may have weekly meetings, weekly reporting and regular supplier visits.

It is good practice for the contract manager to publish, in advance, a schedule to the supplier and those who will be involved in the operation of the contract.

This schedule could include the contract management activities, including objectives and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) and ensure that these are an embedded part of contract management activities from the beginning.  

For a Route 1 contract, which is low value, low risk (or both) this schedule can be very brief.

 


CSM Key Steps

These steps should guide staff through what to expect and what their responsibilities are at each stage. 

This should help staff avoid missteps such as unapproved extensions or inadequate monitoring. 

Please note that the activities listed below are comprehensive and do not all have to be applied at once. Contract managers should make sure that the CSM activities used are proportionate and relevant to the contract that they are managing.  

Please note that a document containing all of the key steps is available for you to download at the bottom of this page.

1. Before the Contract Starts

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • understanding requirement specification/contract scope and deliverables
  • confirm roles and responsibilities
  • review contract documents, KPIs and reporting requirements
  • involvement of procurement
  • risk assessment
  • financial checks

Why it is Important

  • it’s the bridge between procurement and delivery
  • ensures both buyer and supplier understand what’s been agreed, what needs to happen next, and how performance will be measured
  • prevents confusion or misalignment once the contract goes live
  • makes sure the supplier is ready to deliver as promised from day one
  • confirms pricing structures, invoicing processes, and performance measures are clearly understood
  • avoids costly misunderstandings, disputes, or delays later in the contract
  • reduces operational disruption when switching from an outgoing supplier or starting a new service

 

 

2. Contract Award / Handover

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • ensuring documentation is correct and accessible (contract, terms, annexes).
  • contract handover—who does what – complete a contract handover document (a template can be found at the bottom of the page for you to use).
  • ensure contract documentation is accessible.
  • complete handover checklist (a checklist document can be found at the bottom of the page for you to use).
  • once the handover is complete, responsibility for day-to-day performance management sits with the contract manager, with procurement available for advice and escalation.

Why it is Important

  • avoids gaps in knowledge or responsibility
  • transfers all key documentation, risks, decisions, and supplier commitments to the contract manager
  • makes sure everyone understands the contract’s intent, scope, and deliverables before work starts
  • establishes who will manage, monitor, and approve key activities
  • confirms reporting, meeting structures, and escalation routes
  • ensures the right oversight mechanisms are in place from day one (e.g., performance reviews, KPI tracking)
  • sets up systems for invoicing, reporting, risk logs, and performance data
  • confirms all insurances, financial checks, and onboarding requirements are complete
  • makes sure the contract is stored in the right system and accessible to relevant teams
  • reduces the likelihood of early-stage delivery problems or compliance failures

A CSM Handover document and a CSM Handover Checklist are available for you to use, these can be found at the bottom of this page.

3. Monitoring and Reporting

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • for low-risk contracts, monitoring may simply be occasional check-ins and good recording-keeping. Before continuing, consider how much management your contract needs.
  • schedule regular performance meetings (agree frequency of reporting – e.g. monthly, quarterly etc.)
  • what performance data should be tracked (cost, time, quality, supplier risk etc).
  • track KPIs, SLAs, and delivery milestones.
  • record issues and actions taken.
  • maintain accurate records for audit.
  • consider how to capture benefits / savings / sustainable outcomes achieved.

Why it is Important 

  • ensures continual oversight
  • allows identification of trends or issues early
  • confirms that the supplier is delivering the goods, works, or services as specified in the contract — on time, to the right quality, and within budget
  • highlights early if there are any deviations, delays, or performance shortfalls
  • keeps both parties accountable to the agreed Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) or Service Level Agreements (SLAs).
  • without monitoring, you’re managing on assumptions — not evidence
  • regular reports provide clear data on performance, costs, and outcomes
  • enables managers to make informed decisions about renewals, extensions, variations, or corrective actions
  • creates an auditable trail showing how performance was managed and value was achieved
  • confirms that payments are linked to actual performance and outcomes
  • encourages suppliers to focus on continuous improvement and efficiency
  • regular reporting and performance reviews create open communication channels.
  • encourages collaboration, transparency, and shared problem-solving
  • builds trust and helps maintain a positive working relationship — even when issues arise
  • demonstrates that the organisation is managing contracts responsibly, in line with policy, audit, and statutory requirements (e.g. procurement regulations, public spending controls)
  • provides assurance to senior management and auditors that contracts are being managed effectively
  • enables tracking of trends over time — spotting patterns in performance data and identifying opportunities for improvement
  • encourages innovation anvalue through lessons learned and supplier feedback

4. Variations / Extensions / Amendments

Variations (changes to requirements) and extensions to the contract should be exceptional, not routine.

Contract variations should only be permissible where changes do not significantly alter the original contract’s scope, value or duration.

A significant change could be to the:

  • contract scope
  • contract value
  • contract duration

If a proposed change is significant (change in scope, large value increase, much longer duration) then you may need to conduct a new procurement exercise.

If you are unable to estimate the value of a contract that contract will be explicitly made subject to the procurement rules.

If a significant change to the contract is proposed, you must contact your local Procurement Function or Centre of Expertise for advice on how to proceed before making changes.

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • when permitted.
  • process to follow - all changes must follow formal change control procedures.
  • procurement must be involved in significant amendments.
  • escalation should be earlier for high-risk/strategic suppliers, and proportionate.

Why it is Important

  • variation, extension, or amendment changes the terms of a legally binding agreement
  • proper management ensures changes are authorised, documented, and compliant with procurement and governance rules
  • prevents disputes or claims later about what was or wasn’t agreed
  • without a formal process, even small changes can invalidate parts of the contract or create ambiguity
  • public sector organisations must show that all contract changes are fair, transparent, and traceable
  • clear records of variations support audit, governance, and reporting requirements
  • demonstrates accountability for decision-making and use of public funds
  • A structured variation process creates documented evidence of:
  • what changed and why
  • who approved it
  • when it was implemented
  • the impact on cost, scope, and delivery

This is vital for governance, risk management and lessons learned.

A Contract Variation Request Form is available for you to use and can be found at the bottom of this page.

5. Dispute Resolution / Termination / Contract Exit

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • escalate issues early to procurement or legal.
  • follow dispute resolution procedures set out in the contract.
  • document the exit strategy/reasons.

Why it is Important

  • ensures staff know what to do when things go wrong
  • avoids delay or avoidance of necessary action
  • every contract sets out obligations, rights, and remedies for both parties
  • having a clear dispute resolution and termination process ensures the organisation can enforce those rights lawfully if things go wrong
  • prevents informal, inconsistent, or unlawful actions that could lead to legal claims, damages, or reputational harm
  • proper procedures protect both the buyer and supplier — ensuring fairness and due process
  • disputes or terminations are moments of high risk
  • a structured process helps the organisation stay in control, following a calm, documented, and compliant approach rather than reacting under pressure
  • ensures key stakeholders (legal, finance, governance) are engaged early
  • quick, well-managed resolution of issues helps avoid service disruption or cost escalation
  • enables timely negotiation or corrective action before problems worsen
  • if termination is unavoidable, ensures a smooth and cost-effective exit, minimising penalties or loss
  • Your exit strategy should be created/agreed during the Tender stage and revisited at the Contract Award/Handover stage. This can be updated during the lifetime of the contract, if agreed with the supplier(s). If this was not done at the Tender stage, it can be done now in conjunction with the Procurement team. 

A CSM Exit Strategy Template is available for you to use at the bottom of this page.

 


Example of Key CSM Activities

The below sets out some key activities that you may feel are relevant for low value or low risk contracts: 

You can apply the following simplified framework for your own scenario: 

1.Segment the contract (see Route 3 for detailed Segmentation Guidance)

  • Confirm that the contract is truly lower-value / lower-risk (standard items, multiple suppliers possible, non-critical, or easily substituted).
  • Use the Kraljic Matrix to identify it as a “routine” (low impact / low risk) so simpler processes apply.

 2.Before the contract starts

  • Develop contract templates with suitable terms (KPIs, simple clauses) but not overly complex.
  • Include review clauses (price indexation, supply disruption triggers) as appropriate.

3.Contract award/Handover

  • Ensure contract includes Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).
  • Set up periodic review (less frequent than strategic suppliers, but still consistent).

4.Monitoring and Reporting

  • Monitor performance against the agreed KPIs.
  • Maintain basic risk monitoring: e.g. supplier’s supply base changes, logistic/disruption risks, regulatory/compliance issues.
  • Engage supplier proactively: keep communication open even for lower-risk contracts so you are aware of emerging issues early.

5.Contract renewal or termination

  • Before renewal, review performance, market conditions, supply chain risk changes.
  • If performance has been acceptable and risks unchanged, renewal can proceed with minimal negotiation; if changes appear, seek substitute or renegotiate terms.
  • Maintain “off-ramp” planning: even for lower risk contracts, have a fallback plan if the supplier fails.

6.Documentation & risk register

  • Maintain a register of risks (even for low-value contracts) e.g. supply interruptions, price spikes, regulatory changes.
  • Track actions taken to mitigate those risks (dual sourcing, inventory buffer, alternative supplier list).
  • Keep contract repository and clear versioning—so even lower-value contracts are managed, not ignored. 

Case study

Case study

Low-Value / Lower-Risk CSM

Education Authority Northern Ireland (EA) – Food supply contracts

The EA’s Commercial Procurement Service establishes several food contracts supplying ~145,000 school meals daily across Northern Ireland. 

While the total contract value is large (£20 m annually for food contracts) the individual product lines / supplier risk levels are relatively moderate (many standard food items, multiple suppliers). 

Key supplier management / contract-management practices used:

  • Supply-chain mapping: tracing the origin and tiers of supply so that risks (geopolitical, logistic, regulatory) are visible.
    • Dual-sourcing / substitute planning: having backup suppliers or substitute products to reduce risk of supply failure.
    • Early market engagement to assess capacity, continuity of supply, and contractual terms (price-indexation, review clauses) before awarding.
    • Incorporation of human-rights, modern slavery due-diligence clauses—even for relatively standard supplies. 

Outcome: 

Developing and managing constructive and transparent relationships with suppliers ensured that food contracts were successfully executed with minimal disruptions, maximising value for money through improving supplier performance and lowering costs.

Why this qualifies as “low risk / lower value” (relatively): 

The items are standard consumables (food items) with multiple supply sources rather than unique or high-tech components; supply risk is managed via substitution and mapping; contract terms are straightforward and have resilience built in.

Key Message: 

This shows how even for standard, moderate-value contracts you can build in structured supplier management and contract clauses to reduce risk and improve performance.

This Case Study is available in the public domain,  The full case study can be found at:

Case Study for Supply Chain Resilience - Food Contracts | Education Authority Northern Ireland

FAQs - Low Value, Low Risk CSM

1. What is a low value, low risk contract?

A low value, low risk contract typically involves: 

  • A contract value below the regulated procurement threshold (usually under £50,000 for goods/services
  • Minimal business criticality or reputational risk
  • Straightforward requirements with limited supplier dependency and a competitive market

2. Do low value contracts require formal contract management?

Yes — but at a proportionate level. 
Contract management should ensure: 

  • The supplier delivers as agreed
  • Value for money is maintained
  • Any issues or risks are identified early

A light-touch approach is appropriate — for example, simple performance checks and informal review meetings rather than detailed reporting or governance structures. 

3. What documentation is required for low value contracts?

Typically: 

  • Award letter or purchase order (with terms and conditions)
  • Specification or scope of work
  • Basic contract management plan or record, noting key contacts, deliverables, review schedule, and expiry date

For very low value arrangements, a simple record of engagement may be sufficient. 

4. Who is responsible for managing the contract?

Usually, the contract owner or requisitioner within the service area. 
Procurement staff may provide guidance, but day-to-day management (e.g. approving invoices, monitoring delivery) should be handled by the business area benefiting from the contract. 

5. How should supplier performance be monitored?

Use simple, proportionate methods, such as: 

  • Checking delivery times and quality
  • Reviewing invoices against purchase orders
  • Holding occasional check-ins with the supplier
  • Logging any issues and resolutions

A basic performance log or tracker can help maintain accountability. 

6. Do I need a contract management plan?

A formal plan isn’t always required for low value, low risk contracts. 
However, a short summary or checklist noting key deliverables, contacts, and review points supports consistency and audit readiness. 

7. How do I handle poor performance in a low value contract?

  • Raise issues informally first — e.g. email or call to resolve quickly
  • Record actions and outcomes in case escalation is needed
  • If unresolved, follow your organisation’s escalation or contract termination process

Keeping a brief audit trail is recommended, even for low-value cases.

8. What are good practice principles for managing low value contracts?

  • Apply proportionate effort — don’t over-manage
  • Maintain clear communication with the supplier
  • Ensure payments match delivery
  • Record key decisions and outcomes
  • Close the contract properly — confirm final payment, evaluate performance, and record lessons learned.

10. Do low value contracts need to be published on Public Contracts Scotland (PCS)?

Yes, if they were advertised through PCS or awarded following a quick quote. 
However, post-award management can take place locally within the organisation — there’s no need to record every interaction in PCS, unless part of your internal procedure. 

12. How often should low value contracts be reviewed?

At least: 

  • Mid-term (for contracts over one year)
  • Before renewal or re-tender
  • After major issues or complaints

 Otherwise, informal ad-hoc checks are appropriate. 


Additional Context 

 The Scottish Procurement Policy Handbook highlights that the mobilisation stage, clear planning and smooth implementation are key to successful contract outcomes. 


Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Have You Got Everything You Need?

Before carrying on, please check you've got everything you need.

  • Defined the scope of responsibilities (who does what, when)
  • A documented contract management process in place
  • A schedule of contract-management activities agreed with supplier
  • Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) or performance measures for the contract
  • A mechanism for regular review and reporting
  • A clear exit or hand-over plan

 

Organisations should build into their contract management activities sufficient checks to ensure suppliers are meeting their obligations under the General Data Protection Regulations (GDPR).

If obligations are not being met, organisations should take urgent remedial action with the supplier to address issues and risks. 

Contract Award

Once the successful supplier has been identified and approval has been received to award the contract, you can notify suppliers of the outcome.

The successful supplier should be notified of the outcome in writing, using the Contract Award Letter. This must be signed by a person with the delegated authority to procure and commit your Organisation to the contract. The letter may be adapted as required.

At the same time as the above, unsuccessful suppliers should be notified using the Unsuccessful Quotation Letter.

A supplier is entitled to ask for the reasons why their quotation was unsuccessful. It is essential that all feedback is documented for audit purposes and based on the objective criteria used to evaluate the quotation. This is called de-briefing and provides suppliers with positive constructive feedback to help improve their performance in future quotations. It can also provide an opportunity for suppliers to suggest improvements to your procurement processes.

Once the letter has been issued to the successful supplier, the contract becomes live.

Checklist

Checklist

Have you Got Everything You Need?

Before carrying on, please check you've got everything you need:

  • issued a formal Award letter
  • issued unsuccessful letter(s)
  • remember to raise a Purchase Order with the successful supplier
  • a suitable area (either electronic or physical) for storing relevant documentation
  • access to the data is given to all individuals with authority

Any documents you need are listed below

Contract Award Letter

(file type: docx)

Receive and Evaluate Responses

Receipt of Responses

Quotation responses should be received through the Public Contracts Scotland (PCS) Quick Quote system. Quick Quote is a secure way to receive responses and can act as an audit trail if required.  This is considered best practice.

Where organisations do not use Quick Quote, quotation responses may be received in writing or by email. Remember to check your junk mail folder before and after the quotation deadline in case bids have been filtered by your email system.

Opening the Responses

Quotation responses should be opened in line with your organisation's governance arrangements. If your organisation does not use Quick Quote, you should formally record the quotation responses received using the Record of Quotations Received form.

If less than three quotation responses are returned, reasons should be sought from the suppliers who did not submit a bid.  This feedback should be retained on file and can be used as lessons learned for future quotations.

If only one response is received, please contact your local procurement team/Centre of Expertise (CoE) on how to proceed.

Evaluation of Responses

You should use the evaluation process and guidance template to score the responses.  This evaluation will determine which bid best meets your requirements.

Your evaluation should score the evaluation criteria you published in the Invitation to Quote documents.

If you need to seek clarification on any or all quotation responses, this should be sent in writing to the supplier(s).  You should set a specific deadline for supplier(s) to respond with their answer(s) and treat all suppliers on an equal basis.

Abnormally Low Price Response

Any quote which shows an abnormally low price may be queried with the supplier to identify the reason(s) for this. If this is due to supplier error, you should consult with your local procurement team or Centre of Expertise for further advice on how to proceed.

Alternative Terms and Conditions of Contract

If any of the quotation responses are received with alternative Terms and Conditions (T&C’s) of Contract to those you published in your quotation, you must inform the supplier in writing that your original T&C’s of Contract apply.

If the supplier continues to challenge your Terms and Conditions of Contract, you should seek advice from your procurement or legal services team or, in their absence, your relevant Centre of Expertise.

Supplier Interviews and Presentations

In exceptional circumstances, you may consider interviewing/inviting presentations from suppliers in order to assist in the evaluation of quotation responses.  However if you decide to score a supplier presentation as part of the evaluation you should have stated this in the Invitation to Quote documents.

For supplier interviews/presentations, you should provide the suppliers with details of the time, place and format of any interview or presentation, ideally as part of the Invitation to Quote (ITQ).

All suppliers should be treated equally.  Suppliers should be provided with an equal opportunity for interview, presentation or site visits unless the initial evaluation undertaken shows that the supplier could not meet the Invitation to Quote core requirements. 

Records of the interviews/presentations should be kept for audit purposes.

Recommendations Report

Once the evaluation has finished you should complete a recommendations report.  This report is used to present your findings and proposal to your manager/senior management team (in line with your organisation’s governance arrangements) for approval to proceed.

Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Recommendations Report

The recommendations report should contain as a minimum:

  • A summary of the process undertaken
  • Ensure any decisions for supplier disqualification are given
  • Recommendation of award
  • Request for approval

The report should contain reference to the following:

  • Summary of the process to date
  • Ensure any decisions for supplier disqualification have been fully documented and that the paperwork is available for inspection
  • Recommendation of award & request for approval
  • Details of any risks still present and mitigation plans
  • Sustainability considerations (life-cycle costing, social, economic and environmental)
  • Considerations in relation to Community Benefits
  • Details on how the tender outcome will meet the requirements identified in the brief

Checklist

Checklist

Have You Got Everything You Need?

Before carrying on please check you have everything you need.

  • Final scores calculated for all bids
  • Agreement from all evaluators on proposed final scores
  • Approval received to proceed

Any documents you need are listed below

Please note: the Route 1 - Evaluation Process & Guidance Template will be required to be saved to your documents to allow the macro to enable and for the spreadsheet to operate correctly

Declaration of Interest

(file type: docx)

Prepare Documents

To tell potential suppliers what your requirements are, you will need to distribute quotation documents.  These quotation documents need to include information that will help suppliers decide whether they wish to bid or not.

Invitation to Quote Documents

Your Invitation to Quote documents must, as a minimum, include the following:

Checklist

Checklist

Invitation to Quote Documents Checklist

Document Description Included?
Invitation to Quote Letter A covering letter asking suppliers to bid. The Invitation to Quote Letter (ITQ) found below is an example document showing the type of information you can include.   
Brief The document that includes your requirements for the procurement exercise.  The Brief is an example template showing the type of information you can include.  It is important to incude your evaluation criteria - including weightings - in your Brief.  
Your Organisations Terms and Conditions (T&C's) of Contract These will be unique to your organisation and will differ depending on what is being ordered e.g. T&C's for services will differ from T&C's for goods.  Many organisations hold T&C templates for your use.  You should gain approval from your legal department and manager on what T&C's to use and whther clauses need to be added or removed.  
Any Other Information Any information that may affect the supplier's quote should also be included in the ITQ document.  
     
     

Blank rows are provided for your use e.g. to add additional checklist items.

The content of the above templates can be changed to suit your individual requirements.

Organisations should ensure that all relevant procurement documents make reference to the Data Protection Regulations (DPR) and update their terms and conditions accordingly.

You should ask for legal advice to determine how DPR fits with your current quotation requirement and any other documentation used.

How Do I Publish my Invitation to Quote Documents?

You should use the Quick Quote facility on the Public Contracts Scotland (PCS) website wherever possible when seeking quotation bids, ensuring you include the above documents..

If your Organisation does not use Quick Quote, you can also seek quotes in writing or by e-mail.

Issuing Quotation Clarifications or Further Information

Suppliers may ask questions about the published Invitation to Quote documents.  As a result, you may wish to issue further information or provide further clarification not contained within the original document.

In PCS Quick Quote, you can do this via an online bulletin board facility.

Alternatively you can provide clarifications or further information in writing or by e-mail.

If you have issued any clarifications, you should communicate all questions, answers and clarifications in writing to all bidders. This ensures that all bidders are treated fairly and in an open and transparent manner. 

Care should be taken to remove all commercially sensitive information in this process e.g. names of potential suppliers, etc.

Invitation to Quote Timescales

The time limit for quotation responses should reflect the complexity of the requirement and be sufficient for the supplier to make a considered response.

You should keep to your original timescales as included in your Brief document.  In exceptional circumstances, you may choose to consider extending the deadline for receipt of quotations.

An example may be that you have had to issue a clarification/further information to all suppliers.  As a result of this clarification, the suppliers now need more time to work on their quotation document, to be able to respond adequately.

Please remember to communicate any deadline extensions to all potential suppliers. It is advised that you consult with your local Procurement Team/CoE for further guidance.

Checklist

Checklist

Have you Got Everything You Need?

Before carrying on, please check you've got everything you need.

  • Evaluation criteria and weightings agreed and included in the your Brief document, prior to Invitation to Quote publication.
  • Sign off from technical expert and senior management on evaluation criteria and all Invitation to Quote documents.
  • Names and availability of those who will support the answer of supplier's technical or commercial questions
  • Names and availability of those who will evaluate technical or commercial responses.

Any documents you need are listed below