Skip to main content

Additional CSM Guidance

UNDER MAINTENANCE

Demand Management

What is Demand Management?

Demand Management can be defined as:

“the alignment of a business’ consumption with its business requirements”

It is applicable to all goods and services where internal demand and consumption can be influenced to reduce costs.

Demand Management is a key aspect of effectively aligning external resources to meet requirements. When Demand Management is considered, it is often seen as a simple matter of stopping people spending money. However there are ways to look at Demand Management without completely preventing spend.  These can provide notable savings and have a less drastic impact on the business.

Demand often results from internal practices and processes rather than from addressing a real need of the Organisation. The approach is about addressing change ‘in’ an Organisation. Therefore the starting point will be the culture, policy and behaviours of your Organisation.

Your Organisation can also participate by sharing best practice, benchmarking behaviour, creating policy guidance and undertaking peer review.

Demand Management can come at different points in the procurement process. For example, during the initial purchase point e.g. that software licences are purchased for the correct number of users at a single point in time. Demand Management can also occur in situations where costs are recurring as an ongoing activity such as in a category where spend is ongoing and regular (e.g stationery or postal services).

Principles of Demand Management

Demand Management, including behaviour change, represents a significant and untapped opportunity.

In the short termchanging expectations
in the medium termchanging participation
in the long termin the long term

There are 3 main principles of demand management:

1. Each business unit should have exactly what it needs in order to deliver its business objectives;

2. Any resources consumed above this level represents a waste to the Organisation;

3. There may be many and very different ways of meeting a user's needs. Each way represents a different level of resource to achieve the same outcome.

The three strategies listed below could be independently or jointly applied.

EliminateIs the requirement really needed? Can the consumption be stopped? e.g. cancel non-essential meetings, or stop the use of mobile phones for non-business calls. 
ReplaceCan we use lower cost or more effective alternatives? e.g. use video-conferencing for meetings or ensure non-confidential papers are not treated as confidential waste
ReduceCan we use less of a product / service? e.g. don’t order a monitor with every PC purchase or, schedule meetings for the same day

With Demand Management you should consider:

  • a reduction in the demand for goods
  • if there is an option to use recycled goods to avoid buying new? Could recycled goods be supplied under an existing contract?;
  • is there an opportunity to consolidate orders/ services to reduce costs?;
  • improving your purchase to pay system to reduce transactional costs


 

Benefits of Demand Management

There are a number of benefits to an effective Demand Management strategy. Many benefits are driven by:

  • a change in the Organisation culture and outlook; and
  • how goods and services are specified and requested.

When robustly implemented across all goods and services Demand Management drives public sector Organisations’ efficiency and effectiveness. The Organisation uses all  the external resources it procures to meet operational requirements.

The Demand Management process challenges the norms, standards, customs and practices of an Organisation. This is done to a degree not usually found in other processes.

Using Demand Management to prepare Strategic Sourcing, you can establish that the Organisation's requirements are sourced to a very specific level. This can avoid the development of a sourcing strategy for over-specified operational requirements.

Used routinely Demand Management can ensure the highest possible resource levels are directed at front line services. This is especially important in the public sector.

Forecasting Demand

Consideration as to how the demand will be forecasted and fluctuations managed should be initially undertaken at the Shaping the Requirement’ stage. This should be subsequently monitored and managed throughout the lifetime of the contract. Failure to do so could result in:

  • excess material purchases and subsequent material write off/ waste disposal costs;
  • inadequate material availability resulting in additional recovery costs and/ or service breakdown;
  • excess, inadequate or inappropriately positioned resource;
  • reputational damage as a result of service breakdown; and
  • detrimental impact on the end user. 

Effective Demand Management forecasts also give the supply base the opportunity to manage their costs. This can be achieved by positioning resource and materials in line with demand.

Demand forecasting should be based on considerations such as:

  • historical consumption
  • supplier lead times
  • market forces
  • service criticality
  • key stakeholder input
  • purchase cost; and
  • information from other buying organisations, trade bodies and business support organisations e.g. Federation of Small Businesses and Chambers of Commerce, etc.

Where practical, you should look to reduce future demand and costs by using strategies such as:

  • considering if there is an option to fully or partially transition to recycled goods, instead of buying new;
  • reducing transactional cost by improving the purchase to pay system;
  • innovating supplier(s) to reduce mutual cost which should have been previously written into the contract / agreement with the supplier.

For any supplier to operate effectively, it must understand and manage its demand. They can use this knowledge to tailor its resources and processes proportionately.  This will ensure they deliver their service in the most efficient and cost effective manner. By understanding historical demand, an organisation can work with its suppliers to realise mutual cost and efficiency gains.

The most effective way to forecast future demand is to consider a combination of:

  • historical demand;
  • market forces;
  • the Organisation’s business plan/strategic direction.

Forecasting is not an exact science and will never be 100% accurate. However these elements should provide sufficient information to allow the Organisation to develop forecasts. These forecasts should be accurate enough to accommodate demand fluctuations during the lifetime of the contract(s) with minimal cost.

The Organisation should ensure the supplier stays in regular contact with all key stakeholders (including other suppliers).  This will ensure that all parties are aware of the supply/demand position, especially during periods of fluctuation.


Innovation/Value Add

Good Contract and Supplier Management processes should encourage both supplier and organisational innovation. It should be recognised that suppliers often have innovative ideas to improve their own and their customer’s service.  However suppliers can be blocked in their attempts to put these ideas forward.

You should want to be a  customer of choice i.e. suppliers will invest and bring innovation to the contract.  You should adopt these behaviours and allow supplier innovation and added value activity to flourish:

Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

How to Promote Innovation

  • Embrace your suppliers as an extension of your business. Learn from their ideas and build open and trusting relationships where innovation will thrive.
  • Establish a culture of trust and encourage ideas from suppliers, as they often know your business better than some of your own team.
  • Define and share your Organisation's definition of supplier innovation. This way suppliers can understand your internal process, where they fit in and your expectations of them.
  • Share as much information as you can with your top suppliers. The earlier suppliers can see your product / services roadmap, the sooner they can provide ideas to improve it.
  • Implement a consistent governance framework. If a supplier’s idea has potential, assign an internal owner to investigate and develop this ensuring there is accountability and development continuity.
  • Innovation does not have to be ‘ground breaking’. Even minor service or process adjustments can bring cost and/or efficiency gains.
  • Encourage collaboration within the teams. Let them know there will be some ideas that will be more successful than others, but all ideas will be considered. Publicise and reward innovative contributors appropriately.
  • Publicise supplier innovation success stories. A brief email outlining real supplier initiated added-value and the mutual benefits will encourage others to do the same.
  • Consider innovation as a standard KPI and ensure innovation is on the agenda at performance reviews.

Innovation is a two way process.  Your organisation should be equally active in exploring innovative ideas which will help your suppliers improve their performance and service delivery.


Data Protection

Contract management activities must include sufficient checks to ensure suppliers are meeting their Data Protection Legislation obligations as the Processor. These checks  may include audits undertaken by the controller or a third party auditor.

If obligations are not being met, organisations should take urgent remedial action with the supplier to address issues and risks.

More detailed information can be found in Additional Resources.

Overbilling

Weak interactions between an Organisation’s  finance, commercial, and contract management functions provide an opportunity for fraud and overbilling. This could be as a result of error and inefficiency, or by deliberate intent.  

Without basic scrutiny of payments and performance an Organisation’s departments may rely on the supplier to interpret the contract correctly which may result in errors . Better scrutiny of payments and improved contract knowledge within your Organisation will identify any possible overbilling and fraudulent activities Organisations can then take appropriate action.

Fraud Awareness and Prevention

Guidance on fraud can be found in the Additional Resources section of the Procurement Journey

Risk Management

A key element of Contract and Supplier Management is the proactive identification and management of risk. Guidance can be accessed on the Risk Management page.

Blacklisting

Blacklisting refers to the practice of systematically denying individuals employment who would otherwise be able to be employed.  This can be on the basis of information, accurate or not, held in some type of database.

The Scottish Government regards blacklisting or the compiling of a blacklist as unacceptable. 

Effective contract management ensures the practice of blacklisting does not occur in public contracts.

The Employment Relations Act 1999 (Blacklists) Regulations 2010 provide rights for individuals if blacklisting results in refusal of employment, detriment, dismissal or redundancy.  

Any bidder which has been found to have breached, or has admitted breaching, these Regulations must be excluded from the procurement process for a period of three years. This is unless it can demonstrate to you that it has taken appropriate remedial steps.  The Scottish Government regards blacklisting or the compiling of a blacklist as totally unacceptable. Blacklisting refers to the practice of systematically denying individuals employment, who would otherwise be able to be employed, on the basis of information, accurate or not, held in some type of database.

Contract and Supplier Management Guidance for Non-Procurement Staff

Purpose and Scope

This guidance sets out the responsibilities and best practice for staff who are involved in managing contracts and/or engaging with suppliers as part of their role and responsibilities but are not part of the procurement/commercial team.

It applies to all contracts and framework call-offs for goods and services.

It should be used alongside your organisational procurement procedures and relevant Scottish Government policies.


Proportionate Approach

The contract management approach should have been set by the Procurement Team, based on the contract’s value and risk.

Your role is to apply that approach proportionately in day-to-day delivery — e.g. the frequency of check-ins, recording issues early, and escalating sooner for critical services

For more comprehensive CSM guidance, please refer to:

Route 1

Route 2

Route 3


Level of CSM to be Applied

The level of contract and supplier management required for each contract is set during the Tender Stage by the procurement team, based on risk and value

As the person responsible for managing or are using the contract, your role is to apply that agreed approach in practice and flag any changes in risk or service delivery as early as possible.

This means:

  • Using light-touch checks for low value/low-risk contracts
  • Applying more structured monitoring where the contract is critical to your service
  • Letting procurement know if the supplier’s performance, risk profile or circumstances change
  • You do not need to determine the level of CSM yourself.
  • You play a key role in making sure the agreed approach is followed and raising concerns where needed.
  • If you are unsure what level of contract management applies, or think circumstances have changed, please contact your procurement team.

Why CSM Matters

Non-procurement staff often have key roles in:

  • Defining service needs, outputs, outcomes
  • Monitoring supplier performance
  • Managing budgets
  • Handling contract variations or disputes

If there is a lack of clarity or training provided for those staff, risks include non-compliance (legal / regulatory), cost overruns, poor quality, and reputational damage

This guidance is here to help anyone involved in managing or using a contract understand what good practice looks like and how to apply it in a simple, proportionate way.

Good contract management protects services, supports effective supplier relationships, and ensures public funds deliver maximum value.


Roles and Responsibilities

More in depth guidance on Roles and Responsibilities can be found in Route 3

Role Responsibility Examples[L
Contract Owner Accountable for overall contract delivery
  • oversight of KPIs
  • budget holder
  • escalation
Contract Manager Day-to-day management of supplier relationship
  • monitoring performance
  • recording variations
Contract User Orders and/or receives goods or services
  • Ordering goods only from the contracted supplier
  • Reporting delayed deliveries or poor service to the contract manager
Non-procurement Staff Role May also have the role of Contract Owner and/or Contract Manager
  • monitoring delivery / outputs
  • raising issues
  • approving invoices
  • ensuring compliance with performance metrics. 

     

Procurement / Commercial Team Provides professional procurement advice
  • approvals
  • legal compliance
  • change control
Finance Payment controls and budget monitoring
  • invoice approval,
  • compliance with terms
Supplier Deliver goods/services in line with contract
  • meet KPIs,
  • provide reports
  • provide management information/data

 


Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Key Principles of CSM for Non-Procurement Staff

- Value for money / Best Value 
- Legal compliance – public procurement law, Scottish policy etc. 
- Transparency and fairness 
- Ethical standards, conflict of interest 
- Risk management 
- Sustainability (where relevant and proportionate)

These principles underpin decisions and ensure staff act in line with policy. Helps in making judgement calls.

A Contract Compliance Checklist document is available for you to use, these can be found at the bottom of this page.

 


Getting Started

Before you begin contract management, take a moment to get familiar with the basics:

  • locate the contract documents (main contract, service levels, and any schedules or annexes)
  • check who the supplier contact is and how you are expected to communicate with them
  • confirm whether there are known issues already (ask your predecessor/line manager if applicable)
  • check how the supplier is currently monitored (formal meetings or informal check-ins)
  • decide whether the contract is low-risk or higher-risk this will help you understand how much management is needed

 This quick check helps you understand the status of the contract before you start managing performance or escalating issues.

 If you cannot easily find the contract, the owner, or evidence of monitoring, that is itself a risk and should be raised early.


CSM Key Stages 

The following steps should guide staff through what to expect and what their responsibilities are at each stage. This should help staff avoid missteps such as unapproved extensions or inadequate monitoring:

Before the Contract Starts

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • understanding requirement specification/contract scope and deliverables
  • confirm roles and responsibilities
  • review contract documents, KPIs and reporting requirements
  • involvement of procurement
  • risk assessment
  • financial checks

Why it is Important

  • it’s the bridge between procurement and delivery
  • ensures both buyer and supplier understand what’s been agreed, what needs to happen next, and how performance will be measured
  • prevents confusion or misalignment once the contract goes live
  • makes sure the supplier is ready to deliver as promised from day one
  • confirms pricing structures, invoicing processes, and performance measures are clearly understood
  • avoids costly misunderstandings, disputes, or delays later in the contract
  • reduces operational disruption when switching from an outgoing supplier or starting a new service

Contract Award / Handover

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • ensuring documentation is correct and accessible (contract, terms, annexes)
  • contract handover—who does what – complete a contract handover document (a template can be found at the bottom of the page for you to use)
  • ensure contract documentation is accessible.
  • complete handover checklist (a checklist document can be found at the bottom of the page for you to use)
  • once the handover is complete, responsibility for the day-to-day performance management sits with the contract manager - with the procurement team available for advice and escalation (if required)

Why it is Important

  • it’s the bridge between procurement and delivery
  • ensures both buyer and supplier understand what’s been agreed, what needs to happen next, and how performance will be measured
  • prevents confusion or misalignment once the contract goes live
  • makes sure the supplier is ready to deliver as promised from day one
  • confirms pricing structures, invoicing processes, and performance measures are clearly understood
  • avoids costly misunderstandings, disputes, or delays later in the contract
  • reduces operational disruption when switching from an outgoing supplier or starting a new service

A CSM Handover document and a CSM Handover Checklist are available for you to use, these can be found at the bottom of this page.

Monitoring and Reporting

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • for low-risk contracts, monitoring may simply be occasional check-ins and good record-keeping.  Before continuing, refer to the contract handover from the Procurement Team to ascertain the level of contract management that was agreed with the supplier.
  • schedule regular performance meetings (agree frequency of reporting – e.g. monthly, quarterly etc.)
  • what performance data should be tracked (cost, time, quality, supplier risk etc).
  • track KPIs, SLAs, and delivery milestones.
  • record issues and actions taken.
  • use the Balanced Scorecard, if applicable (this can be found at the bottom of this page)
  • maintain accurate records for audit (A Compliance and Audit Checklist document is available at the bottom of the page if it is relevant and proportionate for your contract)
  • consider how to capture benefits / savings / sustainable outcomes achieved

Why it is Important

  • ensures continual oversight
  • allows identification of trends or issues early
  • confirms that the supplier is delivering the goods, works, or services as specified in the contract — on time, to the right quality, and within budget
  • highlights early if there are any deviations, delays, or performance shortfalls
  • keeps both parties accountable to the agreed Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) or Service Level Agreements (SLAs).
  • without monitoring, you’re managing on assumptions — not evidence
  • regular reports provide clear data on performance, costs, and outcomes
  • enables managers to make informed decisions about renewals, extensions, variations, or corrective actions
  • creates an auditable trail showing how performance was managed and value was achieved
  • confirms that payments are linked to actual performance and outcomes
  • encourages suppliers to focus on continuous improvement and efficiency
  • regular reporting and performance reviews create open communication channels.
  • encourages collaboration, transparency, and shared problem-solving
  • builds trust and helps maintain a positive working relationship — even when issues arise
  • demonstrates that the organisation is managing contracts responsibly, in line with policy and statutory requirements (e.g. procurement regulations, public spending controls)
  • provides assurance to senior management  that contracts are being managed effectively
  • enables tracking of trends over time — spotting patterns in performance data and identifying opportunities for improvement
  • encourages innovation and better value through lessons learned and supplier feedback

 The following templates are available for you to use, these can be found at the bottom of this page:

  • A Supplier Performance Review Template,  
  • Meeting Agenda and Minutes Template
  • Balanced Scorecard

Please note that the proportionate level CSM required should have been agreed between the Procurement Team and the Supplier and should set out in the Contract Handover documentation.  If in doubt, please contact your Procurement Team for clarification.

 

Variations / Extensions / Amendments

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • when permitted,
  • process to follow - all changes must follow formal change control procedures
  • procurement must be involved in significant amendments

A Contract Variation Request Form can be found at the bottom of this page

Why it is Important

  • A variation, extension, or amendment changes the terms of a legally binding agreement
  • proper management ensures changes are authorised, documented, and compliant with procurement and governance rules
  • prevents disputes or claims later about what was or wasn’t agreed
  • without a formal process, even small changes can invalidate parts of the contract or create ambiguity
  • public sector organisations must show that all contract changes are fair, transparent, and traceable
  • clear records of variations support audit, governance, and reporting requirements.
  • demonstrates accountability for decision-making and use of public funds
  • A structured variation process creates documented evidence of:
  • what changed and why
  • who approved it;
  • when it was implemented
  • the impact on cost, scope, and delivery.
  • this is vital for governance, risk management, and lessons learned.

 A Contract Variation Request Form is available for you to use and can be found at the bottom of this page, if required. 

Dispute Resolution / Termination

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • escalate issues early to procurement or legal
  • follow dispute resolution procedures set out in the contract

Why it is Important

  • ensures staff know what to do when things go wrong
  • avoids delay or avoidance of necessary action
  • every contract sets out obligations, rights, and remedies for both parties
  • having a clear dispute resolution and termination process ensures the organisation can enforce those rights lawfully if things go wrong
  • prevents informal, inconsistent, or unlawful actions that could lead to legal claims, damages, or reputational harm
  • proper procedures protect both the buyer and supplier — ensuring fairness and due process
  • disputes or terminations are moments of high risk

An Exit Strategy Document is available for you to use, these can be found at the bottom of this page.

Contract Closure, Lessons Learned and Continuous Improvement

Suggested Responsibilities/Considerations

  • conduct post-contract review
  • capture lessons learned
  • conduct lessons-learned workshops after contract closure, if applicable
  • share good practice and case studies across teams
  • the contract Exit Strategy should have been agreed during the Tender Stage by the Procurement Team

Why it is Important

  • helps the organisation learn
  • improves future contract management
  • helps embed good practice
  • ensures that both the supplier and the organisation have completed all deliverables, payments, and reporting

 


Quickfire Guide

Quickfire Guide

Relationships and Communication with Suppliers

Good relationships with suppliers can help avoid conflicts and improve delivery; clear communication ensures expectations are aligned.

  • build collaborative relationships while maintaining compliance.
  • set clear expectations at the start (on both sides).
  • have regular meetings, feedback loops.
  • handle complaints and performance issues constructively.
  • manage supplier risk: financial stability; insurance; subcontractors; change of ownership etc.
  • document all significant conversations and decisions.
  • escalate concerns early

Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest arises when personal, financial, or other interests could compromise (or appear to compromise) the impartial performance of duties in managing or overseeing a contract.

In contract management, this can happen at any stage — from tendering and evaluation to awarding, monitoring, or renewing contracts. Listed below are some of the typed of conflict that can occur:

  1. Actual Conflict

A real and existing conflict between personal interest and professional duty.
 Example: A contract manager awards a contract to a company owned by their spouse.

  1. Perceived (or Apparent) Conflict

When it looks like someone’s personal interests could influence their decisions — even if they don’t.
 Example: A procurement officer socialises regularly with a bidder, creating suspicion of bias.

  1. Potential Conflict

A situation where personal interests could conflict with official duties in the future.
 Example: An employee involved in a tender process later plans to seek employment with one of the bidding companies

 Examples of “Conflict of Interest” in Contract Management 

Stage

Example of Conflict

Contract execution

Overlooking supplier non-performance because of personal relationships.

 

Renewal/extension

Extending a contract without competition due to personal benefit or pressure.

Consequences of Conflict of Interest

  • unfair or biased contract awards

  • legal or regulatory penalties

  • damage to organisational reputation

  • financial losses due to poor value for money

  • internal disciplinary action or termination

Prevention and Management Strategies

Disclosure - Require all employees, evaluators, and consultants to declare any personal or financial interests.

Segregation of Duties - Ensure that no single person controls multiple stages of the contract process.

Conflict of Interest Policy - Implement clear rules and guidance on identifying, declaring, and managing conflicts.

Independent Oversight - Use committees or auditors to review high-value or high-risk contracts.

Training and Awareness - Regular training on ethics, procurement law, and conflict management.

Documentation - Keep detailed records of decisions, declarations, and mitigation measures.


Training & Capability

Under Maintenance


Case study

Case study

Contract and Supplier Management Case Study - For Non-Procurement Staff

Scenario Overview

Organisation: A Scottish public sector body
Department: Community Wellbeing Team (non-procurement staff)
Contract Type: Low-value, low-to-medium risk
Contract Title: Community Support Helpline – Call Handling Service
Supplier: XXX
Contract Value: £42,000 per year
Contract Duration: 2 years + optional 1-year extension
Route to Market: Quick Quote on Public Contracts Scotland (PCS)
Contract Owner: Service Manager (non-procurement professional)
Procurement Support: Corporate Procurement Unit (CPU) at award stage only

Background

The organisation operates a community support helpline offering advice, information, and onward referral. Due to changes in service demand, the organisation outsourced call-handling for out-of-hours operations.

The CPU supported the tender and award, but ongoing contract and supplier management responsibilities sit with operational staff, mostly with no formal procurement training.

This case study demonstrates how non-procurement staff can manage a contract effectively and proportionately.

Objectives of the Contract

  1. Ensure callers receive accurate, confidential, and timely advice.
  2. Maintain high-quality service delivery in line with Scottish public sector values.
  3. Ensure value for money throughout the contract period.
  4. Comply with Data Protection, Information Governance and Cyber Security requirements.
  5. Maintain supplier performance and avoid service disruption.

Stakeholders

Service Manager - Contract Owner & Day-to-Day Manager

Helpline Team Lead - Monitors performance data & logs issues

CPU (Procurement Team) - Provides advice on changes, disputes, extensions

Finance Team - Manages invoices and budget

Supplier Account Manager -Single point of contact for service queries

Information Governance Officer -Advises on data/Breach management

 

Key Contract Requirements

Performance Standards

  • 90% of calls answered within 20 seconds
  • 95% accuracy in information provided
  • Monthly performance reporting required
  • Staff must complete mandatory safeguarding and GDPR training

Quality Requirements

  • Call logs must be auditable
  • Complaints logged within 24 hours
  • No more than 1 data breach per year

Commercial Terms

  • Fixed annual fee invoiced monthly
  • Deductions apply if KPIs repeatedly fall below agreed thresholds

Risk Level

  • Service continuity risk (medium)
  • Data protection risk (medium)
  • Financial risk (low)

Contract and Supplier Management Approach

Because this is a low-value/low-to-medium risk contract, the management approach is proportionate, but still structured.

Activities Managed by Non-Procurement Staff

Service Monitoring

  • Review monthly performance dashboards
  • Check call response time trends
  • Listen to sample call recordings quarterly
  • Monitor complaint volumes

Relationship Management

  • Hold monthly virtual meetings with the supplier
  • Maintain a clear, issue log
  • Escalate repeated concerns to the CPU

Financial Management

  • Verify monthly invoices against call volume and reports
  • Flag discrepancies to Finance and CPU

Risk & Compliance Oversight

  • Ensure GDPR and confidentiality training certificates are up to date
  • Log near misses or potential data issues internally
  • Raise concerns promptly with Information Governance

Issues That Arose During the Contract

Issue 1: Decline in Call Answer Rates

In months 4–5, call-answering performance dropped to 82% due to supplier staff shortages.

Actions Taken:

  • Logged the issue in the performance tracker
  • Raised it in monthly meeting
  • Supplier provided recovery plan including temporary staffing
  • KPI returned to 90% within 2 months

Learning Point for Non-Procurement Staff:
Performance issues should be recorded, discussed, and monitored, not ignored.

 

Issue 2: Incorrect Information Given to a Caller

A vulnerable caller was misinformed about emergency support availability.

Actions Taken:

  • Logged incident in issue log
  • Conducted a joint call review
  • Supplier retrained staff and updated call scripts
  • No further issues occurred

Learning Point:
Non-procurement managers should feel confident to raise quality concerns—they are central to protecting service users.

 

Issue 3: Invoice Discrepancy

Supplier invoiced £4,000 instead of the contractually agreed £3,500 for one month.

Actions Taken:

  • Service Manager cross-checked contract
  • Finance queried invoice
  • Supplier corrected it

Learning Point:
Basic commercial checks prevent over-payments and maintain contract integrity. 

 

End-of-Year Supplier Review

A formal annual review was held between the non-procurement contract manager, CPU, and the supplier.

Outcomes

  • KPIs met for 9 of 12 months
  • Data protection processes improved
  • Customer satisfaction remained high
  • Supplier requested early discussion about optional extension year

Decision:

The organisation agreed (subject to CPU review) that extending the contract was appropriate because:

  • Performance improved
  • No major risks outstanding
  • Market testing not required for low-risk continuation

     

Lessons Learned for Non-Procurement Staff

  1. You do not need to be a procurement expert to manage a contract well.
    Following structured processes and using CPU support is enough for most low-to-medium risk contracts.

     

  2. Document everything.
    Issue logs, meeting notes, and performance records provide important information for continuous improvement and are vital evidence that help solve problems that may arise. 

     

  3. Be proactive with supplier relationships.
    Engage regularly—not only when things go wrong.  Good supplier relationships offer opportunities to share good practices and encourage joint problem solving and a positive attitude to contract delivery.

     

  4. Understand the basics of the contract.
    Read the specification, KPIs, and pricing schedule at minimum.

     

  5. Use procurement support appropriately.
    CPU should be involved for variations, extensions, disputes, and legal questions.

     

  6. Protect service users and organisational reputation.
    Risk management is not just a procurement task—it's everyone’s responsibility, training should be sought for non-procurement staff where needed.

Legal & Policy Foundations in Scotland


FAQs -  Contract and  Supplier Management for Non-Procurement Staff

What is contract and supplier management?

Contract and supplier management is the day-to-day management of a contract after it has been awarded. It focuses on:

  • Making sure goods or services are delivered as agreed
  • Managing the relationship with the supplier
  • Monitoring performance, costs, and risks
  • Ensuring public money is spent properly

Why do non-procurement staff have a role in this?

Non-procurement staff are often:

  • The main users of the service
  • Closest to delivery and performance issues
  • Best placed to spot risks or value-for-money concerns

Your role helps ensure contracts deliver what was paid for.

What am I responsible for (and what am I not responsible for)?

You are responsible for:

  • Using the contract correctly
  • Monitoring delivery and performance
  • Raising and recording issues
  • Managing routine supplier contact
  • Ensure goods or services are delivered as agreed
  • Check invoices before approval
  • You are not expected to be a procurement expert

You are not responsible for:

  • Running procurement exercises
  • Negotiating new contract terms
  • Agreeing price changes or extensions without approval

Why is contract and supplier management important in the Scottish public sector?

It helps ensure:

  • Proper use of public funds
  • High-quality services
  • Legal and regulatory compliance
  • Transparency and public trust

Non-procurement staff play a key role in achieving these outcomes.

Where can I find the contract information I need?

You should have access to:

  • The signed contract or call-off agreement
  • Specification / statement of requirements
  • Pricing and payment terms
  • KPIs or service levels

These are usually stored in a contract register, contract handover document, shared drive or contract management system.

How much contact should I have with the supplier?

You should:

  • Communicate professionally and fairly
  • Keep discussions focused on contract delivery
  • Keep a written record of key conversations and decisions

Avoid informal agreements or commitments outside the contract.

What should I do if the supplier is not meeting expectations?

You should:

  1. Check what the contract says
  2. Raise the issue with the supplier
  3. Agree corrective actions and timescales
  4. Record the issue and actions taken
  5. Escalate if performance does not improve

Do not ignore issues or accept reduced service without approval from your Procurement Team

What should I do if there’s a minor issue with the supplier?

You should:

  1. Raise the issue with the supplier
  2. Agree a simple fix or correction
  3. Keep a brief record (e.g. email)

If issues repeat or escalate, involve your manager or Procurement.

Can I ask the supplier to change the service or scope?

No — not informally.
Any change to scope, cost, duration, or deliverables must:

  • Follow a formal variation process
  • Be assessed for value for money and compliance
  • Be approved by the appropriate authority

Always involve Procurement if a change is proposed.

When should I involve Procurement?

You should contact Procurement if:

  • A supplier requests changes
  • Performance issues persist
  • You are unsure what the contract allows
  • A contract is nearing expiry
  • There are compliance or value-for-money concerns

What is a contract variation?

A contract variation is a formal, approved change to the contract.
It ensures:

  • Changes are lawful and transparent
  • Risks are assessed
  • Audit requirements are met

Verbal or informal changes are not permitted.

Can I approve invoices from suppliers?

Yes, if you are authorised and:

  • The invoice matches the contract
  • The service or goods have been delivered
  • Any variations have been formally approved

If something looks incorrect, you should query it before payment.

What records do I need to keep?

You should keep records of:

  • Key supplier communications
  • Performance reports or reviews
  • Issues, risks, and actions
  • Variations, extensions, or approvals

Good records support audit, transparency, and accountability.

What is a conflict of interest?

A conflict of interest arises when personal interests could influence (or appear to influence) decisions.

Examples include:

  • Personal relationships with supplier staff
  • Gifts or hospitality
  • Financial interests

All conflicts must be declared in line with your organisation’s policy.

Can contracts be extended automatically?

No.

Contracts can only be extended if:

  • An extension option exists in the contract
  • The extension is compliant with procurement regulations
  • The correct approvals are obtained

Always plan ahead and involve Procurement early.

Do I need to monitor low-value or low-risk contracts?

Yes.

While monitoring may be lighter, you must still:

  • Check delivery
  • Confirm invoices are correct
  • Record issues

Public sector accountability applies to all contracts.

What does “low-value / low-risk” contract mean?

A low-value / low-risk contract is one where:

  • The financial value is relatively small
  • The service or goods are routine or standard
  • There is limited impact if something goes wrong

Even so, public money and public sector rules still apply.


Any documents you need are listed below

  • Balanced Scorecard (use existing, improved version)
  • Supplier performance review template (use existing)
  • Meeting agenda and minutes template (to be drafted)

Exit Strategy Template

(file type: docx)

Case Studies and FAQs

Case study

Case study

Example Case Study: High-Value, High-Risk Contract & Supplier Management

Project Overview

Organisation: XXX
Contract Title: National Intelligent Transport Infrastructure Modernisation Programme
Contract Value: £100 million over 7 years
Risk Level: High value / high risk
Procurement Route: Competitive Procedure with Negotiation (CPN) under the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations
Supplier: Large multi-national infrastructure and ICT provider
Purpose: Upgrade national network of roadside sensors, traffic management systems, and data platforms to improve safety, analytics, and real-time public information.

Why the Contract Was High-Risk

Strategic and Operational Importance

  • This infrastructure underpins safety-critical systems (e.g., variable speed limits, incident detection)
  • Failure would have direct public safety impact

Complex Multi-Technology Solution

  • Integration of ageing legacy infrastructure with new digital systems
  • Significant cyber security requirements
  • Dependence on interoperability between multiple Scottish public bodies

Supplier Market Conditions

  • Very limited supplier market (only 3 global providers)
  • Known risk of over-reliance on one provider creating long-term lock-in

Financial & Commercial Exposure

  • Long-term technology contracts historically have cost-creep risks
  • Supplier previously had delivery delays on large UK programmes

Procurement Stage Risk Management

Early Market Engagement

XXX conducted:

 Prior Information Notice (PIN) with supplier briefings

  • Discovery sessions with potential suppliers to test feasibility and innovation
  • Publication of standardised SPD statements for consistent supplier responses

Robust Specification & Outcomes-Based Requirements

  • Performance standards for system up-time, incident detection accuracy, and data latency
  • Mandatory cyber-security controls aligned to Scottish Government Cyber Resilience Framework
  • Clear exit and data handover requirements to prevent supplier lock-in

Multi-Stage Evaluation

  • Technical capability weighting = 65%
  • Commercial/price weighting = 35%
  • Inclusion of scenario-based assessments and live demonstrations of key functionalities

Detailed Risk Allocation

  • Supplier responsible for system performance and integration
  • Authority retained responsibility for policy, governance, and network access permissions
  • Shared risk register established before contract award

Contract Management Framework (Post-Award)

Governance Structure

Strategic Level (Quarterly)

  • Senior Responsible Owner (SRO)
  • Supplier’s Programme Director
  • Independent Assurance Consultant
  • Focus on: strategic risks, contract changes, long-term road map

Tactical Level (Monthly)

  • Contract Manager
  • Supplier Account Manager
  • Performance and risk leads
  • Review of KPIs, milestones, financials, workforce, supply chain, and cyber security posture

Operational Level (Weekly)

  • Project delivery teams
  • Issue logs, work package progress, testing results

 Key KPIs and Performance Measures

AreaKPI ExampleTarget
System AvailabilityUp-time of traffic control platform99.95%
Incident DetectionAccuracy of automated sensors> 96%
Cyber securityPatch deployment time< 48 hrs
Delivery MilestonesInfrastructure roll out95% on time
Social ValueLocal SME engagement18% of contract value

Contract Management Issues & Response

Issue 1: Supplier Delays on Critical Milestones

The Supplier fell 9 weeks behind schedule during Phase 1 due to shortages in specialist engineers.

Mitigation Actions

  • Invoked the contract’s remedy plan clause requiring a detailed recovery plan within 10 working days
  • A joint task-force was created including XXX technical specialists
  • Supplier re-allocated additional resources from EU teams at their own cost
  • Milestone re-baselining approved with no increase in contract price

Issue 2: Cyber security Vulnerability

Independent assurance testing discovered a medium-severity vulnerability in the cloud analytics module.

Mitigation Actions

  • Immediate escalation to Strategic Board
  • Supplier required to deploy emergency patch within 72 hours (as per contract)
  • Additional penetration testing introduced quarterly

Issue 3: Supplier Financial Health Concerns

Market analysis revealed the Supplier parent company experienced losses in two consecutive quarters.

  • Mitigation Actions
  • Financial monitoring increased from quarterly to monthly
  • Supplier required to provide updated financial statements and parent-company guarantees
  • Contingency planning for partial or full supplier failure (including alternative suppliers and in-sourcing scenarios)

Continuous Improvement and Social Value Delivery

The supplier delivered several social and economic benefits:

  • Apprenticeship programme with Scottish colleges (14 apprentices across digital engineering)
  • Local supply chain development with 22 Scottish SMEs
  • Traffic safety educational sessions delivered to schools in deprived areas.
    XXX tracked these commitments quarterly against the Fair Work and Community Benefits requirements

Contract Close-Out & Lessons Learned

Positive Outcomes

  • National intelligence transport system modernised on time (after early recovery) and on budget
  • Incident response times improved by 19%
  • Availability levels exceeded the contractual requirement (achieved 99.95%)

Key Lessons Learned

  1. Early, structured risk allocation prevented costly disputes later
  2. Strong governance enabled quick escalation and resolution of issues
  3. Independent assurance was critical to managing a complex digital contract
  4. Market concentration risk must be continually monitored
  5. Embedding exit planning from the start avoided long-term dependency